Why Customers Churn: The Real Reasons SaaS Users Cancel

You can’t fix churn if you don’t understand why it’s happening. And most founders don’t.

They look at the number going up, panic, and start throwing solutions at it. Better onboarding. More emails. New features. But if you’re solving for the wrong problem, you’re wasting time.

This post breaks down the real reasons customers churn, how to figure out which ones apply to you, and what to do about each. Once you understand the causes, you can check our guide on how to reduce SaaS churn for specific tactics.

Voluntary vs Involuntary Churn

Before we get into specific reasons, you need to understand the two types of churn. They require completely different fixes.

Voluntary churn is when customers actively decide to cancel. They logged in, clicked the cancel button, and left. This is the type most people think about.

Involuntary churn is when customers leave without meaning to. Their credit card expired. The payment failed. They forgot to update their billing info. They didn’t want to leave, but technically they did.

Here’s why this matters: involuntary churn typically accounts for 20-40% of total churn. That’s a huge chunk of customers you’re losing who actually wanted to stay. If you’re not tracking these separately, you might be solving the wrong problem.

How to tell the difference: Look at your cancellation data. Did they click cancel? Voluntary. Did the subscription end due to payment failure? Involuntary. Most billing systems track this.

The Top Reasons for Voluntary Churn

Based on exit surveys, customer interviews, and industry research, here are the most common reasons customers actively choose to leave:

1. They Never Got Value

This is the biggest one. The customer signed up, maybe poked around for a few days, never really “got it,” and left.

They didn’t experience the core value of your product. Maybe onboarding was confusing. Maybe they didn’t understand how to use key features. Maybe they had a problem your product solves but never connected the dots.

How to spot it: Look at your time-to-cancel data. If most cancellations happen in the first 30-90 days, this is likely your problem. Also look at feature usage before cancellation. Did they ever use your core features?

The fix: Improve onboarding. Get users to your “aha moment” faster. Remove friction. Send helpful guidance in the first week.

2. The Problem Went Away

Sometimes customers leave because they no longer need your product. The project ended. They pivoted. The problem you solve isn’t a problem for them anymore.

This is often unavoidable, and that’s okay. Not all churn is bad churn. If someone genuinely doesn’t need your product anymore, them leaving is the right outcome.

How to spot it: Exit surveys and interviews. If customers say “we don’t need this anymore” or “the project ended,” this is what’s happening.

The fix: There’s not much you can do about legitimate use case changes. Focus your energy on other causes. Though you can try to expand use cases so customers have more reasons to stay.

3. They Found Something Better

Sometimes customers leave because they found a product that fits their needs better, costs less, or is easier to use.

This stings, but it’s useful information. If you’re consistently losing customers to the same competitor, that tells you something about your positioning or feature gaps.

How to spot it: Ask in exit surveys: “Are you switching to another product? Which one?” Track patterns over time.

The fix: Competitive analysis. Figure out what they’re offering that you’re not. It might be features, pricing, UX, or positioning. Not every gap is worth closing, but you should understand what’s happening.

4. Budget Cuts and Business Changes

Startups fail. Companies cut costs. Teams get reorganized. Budgets get slashed. None of this has anything to do with your product.

If you sell to startups or SMBs, this is a structural reality. Some percentage of your customers will simply stop existing or stop having budget. Enterprise customers are more stable but not immune, especially during economic downturns.

How to spot it: Look at whether the company is still operating. Check if they’re downgrading first (a sign of budget pressure) or canceling outright.

The fix: You can’t prevent businesses from failing. But you can target more stable customer segments, offer cheaper tiers for customers under budget pressure, or focus on becoming essential enough to survive budget cuts.

5. They Feel Ignored

Customers leave when they think you don’t care about them. They submitted feedback that went nowhere. They asked for a feature and never heard back. They feel like the product isn’t evolving in ways that help them.

This is particularly common with SaaS products where there’s no visible sign of development. If customers don’t see progress, they assume there is none.

How to spot it: Look at customers who submitted feedback or support tickets before churning. Did they get responses? Was their feedback acknowledged?

The fix: Build a visible feedback loop. Public roadmaps and feedback boards show customers you’re listening and building. Tools like UserJot let customers see the journey from request to shipped feature, which makes them feel invested rather than ignored.

6. Support Failed Them

A bad support experience can undo months of good product experience. When customers hit a wall and can’t get help, frustration builds fast.

This is especially damaging when the support issue blocks their work. If they can’t do their job because of your product and can’t get help, they’re going to look for alternatives.

How to spot it: Look at support ticket history for churned customers. Were there unresolved issues? Long response times? Negative sentiment?

The fix: Track response times and resolution quality. Prioritize blocking issues. Make sure customers can get help when they need it.

7. The Price Didn’t Match the Value

Sometimes customers leave because they’re paying more than they feel the product is worth. This isn’t always about being “too expensive” in absolute terms. It’s about the perceived value relative to the price.

A customer paying $50/month who uses the product daily might feel great about the value. A customer paying $50/month who uses it once a week might feel ripped off.

How to spot it: “Too expensive” in exit surveys is a signal, though it’s often a proxy for other issues. Look at usage patterns for churned customers compared to retained ones.

The fix: Align pricing with value delivered. Consider usage-based pricing elements. Offer downgrade paths before cancellation.

The Top Reasons for Involuntary Churn

Involuntary churn is often overlooked, but it’s easier to fix than voluntary churn. These customers already want to stay.

1. Payment Failure

Credit cards expire. Banks flag transactions. Accounts get closed. Payment methods change. If your billing fails and you don’t recover it, you lose the customer.

How to spot it: Your billing system should flag payment failures. Track how many subscriptions end due to failed payments vs active cancellations.

The fix: Retry failed payments automatically. Send friendly email sequences when payments fail. Use dunning management tools. Make it easy to update payment info.

2. Forgotten Subscriptions

Sometimes customers forget they’re subscribed. They signed up for a trial, never used the product, and didn’t realize they were being charged until months later. When they notice, they cancel.

How to spot it: Look at usage data for customers who cancel. Did they ever log in after signup? Were they active at all?

The fix: Remind inactive customers that they’re subscribed and paying. This feels counterintuitive, but it’s better than surprising them with months of unwanted charges. Some will cancel, but some will start using the product. And you avoid chargebacks and angry reviews.

3. Account or Card Changes

Customers change companies. Corporate cards get replaced. Bank accounts close. The person who signed up might not even work at the company anymore, and nobody thought to update the billing.

How to spot it: Multiple failed payment attempts before the subscription ends, especially for older accounts.

The fix: Annual billing reminder emails before renewal. Easy ways to update payment info. Reach out when payments start failing.

How to Diagnose Your Churn

Knowing the reasons is only useful if you can figure out which ones apply to you. Here’s how to do that:

Step 1: Separate Voluntary and Involuntary

Start by splitting your churn data into these two buckets. If 30% of your churn is involuntary, you should probably fix that first since it’s usually easier.

Step 2: Look at Time-to-Churn

When do customers cancel? Plot the distribution.

• Heavy churn in first 30 days: Onboarding and activation problem
• Heavy churn around 60-90 days: Value realization problem
• Steady churn throughout: Multiple causes, need to dig deeper
• Spikes after price changes: Pricing problem

Step 3: Segment by Customer Type

Different customers churn for different reasons. Look at:

• Plan level: Do free or low-tier customers churn more?
• Acquisition channel: Do paid acquisition customers churn more than organic?
• Company size: Do startups churn more than established companies?
• Use case: Do certain use cases have higher churn?

Step 4: Actually Talk to Churned Customers

Exit surveys get you data. Exit interviews get you understanding.

Email 20 churned customers and ask for a 10-minute call. Offer a gift card if needed. Ask open-ended questions: “Walk me through your decision to cancel.”

The patterns that emerge from these conversations are usually more actionable than survey data.

Step 5: Look at What They Did Before Leaving

For voluntary churn, review the customer’s journey:

• What features did they use (or not use)?
• Did they contact support? What about?
• Did they submit feedback? What did they ask for?
• When did usage start declining?

This behavioral data often tells you more than what customers say.

---

What To Do Next

Once you understand why customers are churning, you can start fixing it. But prioritize ruthlessly.

If 35% of your churn is failed payments, fix that first. It’s the easiest win. If most of your churn happens in the first month, focus on onboarding. If customers are leaving for competitors, dig into what’s different.

For specific tactics on fixing each cause, check out our guide on how to reduce SaaS churn. For context on whether your churn rate is actually a problem, see our SaaS churn benchmarks.

The companies that win at retention aren’t the ones who implement the most tactics. They’re the ones who understand their specific churn causes and focus on fixing those.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the number one reason customers churn?

The most common reason for voluntary churn is that customers never experienced the core value of the product. They signed up, didn’t “get it,” and left. For involuntary churn, payment failure is the top cause. Addressing both of these typically has the biggest impact on overall churn.

What percentage of churn is involuntary?

Involuntary churn, primarily from payment failures, accounts for 20-40% of total churn at most SaaS companies. This is often overlooked because it’s less visible than active cancellations, but it’s usually easier to fix.

How do I find out why customers are churning?

Use multiple methods: exit surveys for quantitative data, exit interviews for qualitative understanding, behavioral analysis to see what customers did before leaving, and cohort analysis to identify patterns by customer type, time period, or acquisition channel.

Is it normal for startups to have higher churn?

Yes. Early-stage companies typically have higher churn for several reasons: product-market fit isn’t fully established, features may be missing, onboarding isn’t optimized, and often they’re targeting early adopters who have higher expectations. Churn usually decreases as the product matures.

Should I try to win back churned customers?

It depends on why they left. Customers who churned due to payment failure or temporary budget issues are good candidates for win-back campaigns. Customers who left for competitors or because the problem went away are harder to recover. Focus win-back efforts on segments with a realistic chance of returning.

How do I tell if churn is a product problem or a customer problem?

Look at your best customers vs your churned customers. If your retained customers have certain characteristics (company size, use case, acquisition channel) that churned customers lack, you might be acquiring the wrong customers. If retained and churned customers look similar but behave differently, it’s more likely a product or onboarding issue.